Reader
Open on CHYOA

Pin Dick Peter

"Oh Fuck!" The stacked blonde squealed as the foot long cock slammed into her clean shaven pussy. "You're so big! So fucking big!" A moment later, another huge shaft speared into her moaning mouth, silencing her as the thick cock roughly fucked her throat. Her sweaty body was bounced back and forth as she was impaled by the two monster cocks on either end. Her eyes rolled back in her head as another orgasm wracked her body, in ecstasy from the rough use of her body.

Peter watched the blonde get mercilessly fucked on his computer screen as he jerked his own cock furiously. The video was one of his favorites because the gorgeous blonde in it, was almost a dead ringer for his long-time friend, Haley. As he stroked his own shaft, he tired to imagine himself fucking the girl he had known for years just like the cocks on the screen, but Peter was unfortunately not as well endowed as either of the male pornstars in the video.

Peter was an average looking eighteen-year-old guy, not a total hunk but not ugly either. He got his fair share of dates in high school with a number of attractive young ladies. The one thing that was not average about Peter, however, was his penis.

At about 4 inches, and not too thick either, Peter's penis was seriously underwhelming. He could wrap his fingers around it when erect and almost completely cover it. His testicles were average size, but this only made his shaft look even smaller in comparison. When it was soft, his penis practically rested on his balls.

So far, Peter had been quite lucky in keeping his 'short coming' a secret. He had managed to keep it a secret from everyone, including his family, with two exceptions.

The first was his family doctor, Dr. Schwartz. Peter had been in for a routine check up several years ago and built up the bravery to ask his doctor if there was anything he could do to improve his penis situation. The elderly doctor had been sympathetic to Peter, but let him know that there weren't any magic pills or pumps that could increase his size down there. The good doctor did Peter a favor and wrote his a pass for school that exempted him from gym, preventing him from having to put his small dick on display in the gym showers. Dr. Schwartz also promised to keep the information a secret between them, even from teenage Peter's parents, and he stayed true to his word.

The other person was not as trustworthy, however.

Peter had gone to a kegger party last fall after homecoming, hosted at the home of a classmate whose party were away for the weekend. A bit too drunk to be as cautious as usual about revealing his secret, He had hooked up with Christy, a pretty girl who was quite popular with the boys at her school because she was a bit of a slut. In an empty spare bedroom, Christy had eagerly worked Peter's pants off but paused when she caught sight of Peter's puny but achingly hard erection. She glanced up at his face in surprise, stifled a giggle, and wordlessly went to work giving Peter a skilled blowjob. Peter lost control in less than a minute, and shot his load into her mouth before he could warn her. Obviously used to having guys cum in her mouth, Christy swallowed the salty load and then wiped her lips with the back of her arm. As she stood up, she said blandly, "With a dick as small as yours, I'd work on my stamina." and then left Peter standing alone in the dark bedroom. He hadn't spoken to her since.

As Peter shot his load across his belly, he turned off the video of the double stuffed blonde and reached for the tissues. He cleaned up his mess and then crawled into bed, spent and satisfied, and quickly drifted off to sleep.

He might not have slept so well if he knew that tomorrow, someone else was going to find out about his little secret...

What's next?

Log in or Sign up to continue reading!