Arm Wrestling Stories

168,625 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Phoenix Files: Crazy Meets Loony

by Phoenix on Sep 12, 2017
Celebrities & Fan Fiction

I was on my way to my hotel room after that asshole Orton debacle. Truth be told I took more out of myself in that match than my opponents did. Maybe I should tone down some of my risks or I might end up like Jeff Hardy. Destroyed, disenfranchised, and discontinued at 26 years old. As I slid my keycard I felt someone wrap their arms around me and grab my p...

Latina Targets Wrestling Stud

by HerMatman on Jul 16, 2019
Erotic Couplings

The wrestling team had talked about Maria (25 yrs.) three years ago. She was known as the Latina who loved giving blow jobs to wrestlers. Rumor had it that she got married and quit the university. That was just a rumor because Maria had returned to school and she isn't married either. The university holds a weekend wrestling tournament and had invited 5 ot...

Wrestling with Friends

by sterlingdaydream on Jan 20, 2020
Group Sex

Just a heads up: there is a pretty fair amount of guy on guy contact in this story, so if that's not your thing this might not be your story. Everybody's 18. *** It was just another typical Saturday afternoon, Will and Matt were doing what they usually did on a Saturday afternoon, playing video games at Matt's house while talking about the hot girls from h...

The Bleach Blonde's Wrestler Pt. 03

by HerMatman on Mar 18, 2020
Erotic Couplings

Sarah (30 yrs.) is the former wife (44-24-36) of a state senator. She owns a small penthouse in the city. She's a cheap looking, bleach-blonde, who is a big fan of college wrestling. She never goes to the local wrestling meets, but watches every live competition on YouTube. She follows all of the athletes and coaches on social media. Cooper (19 yrs.) stand...

Never Too Old

by Catullus_Sedecim on Dec 24, 2019
Non-Erotic

Billy was a good wrestler. Some would go so far as to call him a great wrestler. They would have reason to, as well, at the age of 19 he was an All-American and national champion in his college wrestling division, and during the off-season, when he returned from snowy Michigan to his home in suburban Texas? Well, he was a champion there, too, at the local gy...

Unbeaten Challenge - Nikki Storm

by daxg2001 on Sep 15, 2017
Celebrities & Fan Fiction

WARNING: The following is a work of erotic fan fiction, the events of which are completely made up and did not happen, and is no true reflection of the persons, wrestlers, events, promotions etc depicted within. This material is unsuitable to be viewed by those under the legal age limit of viewing pornographic material in your current country of residence....

Alexa

by Ha275 on Sep 17, 2017
Celebrities & Fan Fiction

"Wrestling is fake." said a guy to Alexa Bliss as she watched a replay of herself from last night's show at the 7/11 store. The hot blonde looked at him and smiled away perhaps mocking his fat stomach and beefy limbs. The guy put his hand on her shoulder and said "Don't walk away with that look bitch! I'll beat the shit out of you anywhere anytime." She...

Amsterdam Ch. 01

by Louetta on Oct 16, 2018
Fetish

As I mention from time to time, my Mother was born in The Netherlands where her parents and her sister and her family still live. Over the years we have made an effort to get together every two years, alternating between us going there and them coming here. Now that we are older, I'm pushing thirty three as I write this, the participants have changed a bit....

Angel Wrestling League Ch. 01

by Stipend on Oct 6, 2020
BDSM

"Number 43. Why did I have to be number 43? Why can't I wrestle today?" I thought to myself as I showed up to work the next morning. Last night, I had been assigned a number in the Angel Wrestling League, a sex wrestling league of 200 women that had millions of fans worldwide. When I went to check the schedule I saw that I was paired up with wrestler number...

Submitting to the Sultan Ch. 03

by LukaWolff on Nov 26, 2018
Fetish

Note: This story includes M/F, M/M, piss play, dominance & submission, and incest, and all characters are at least 18 years of age. Also please note that this story is set in a historical fantasy world that, though it shares many similarities with our own, isn't intended to literally represent a specific area. ***** Though it was earlier than they generall...