Butt Plug Stories

1,000 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll
SmutMD: The World's Biggest Erotic Literature Search Engine.
© 2026 SmutMD.com

Passion Plug

by jasliz on Sep 12, 2017
Anal

The butt plug was enormous and firmly in her perfectly formed ass. I had no idea how she got it in to begin with, but it was there when I pulled her thong down. Her pussy was flushed, already engorged and wet. Grabbing the plug I began to play, pulling it out and watching in amazement at how wide it was. She moaned, kneeling on the couch in my apartment as I...

The Butt Plug

by Diamond_Girl on Sep 16, 2017
Toys & Masturbation

"Arane." "Mmmbbbmm." "Ara-ane." "Hummpt." "Arane, honey, it's time to wake up." Your smooth, sexy, sleep-roughened baritone vibrates against my back as you breathe a wake-up into my ear. Your warm chest feels heavenly where it presses into my back, and your arms hold me close to you. I nestle in deeper, wriggling my hiney against the now very evident st...

The Butt Plug

by SlutsAndRainbows on Sep 12, 2017
Anal

Completely naked, her wrists are bound tightly together with rope in front of her. Her ankles are attached to a long spreader bar. She was leaning uncomfortably on her knees and elbows facing the headboard of the bed. Her head lowered, she waited for what felt like an eternity for her Master when she heard Him move which made her jump. He chuckled to Himself...

Tree Hugger Loves Butt Plugger

by BrookMeier on Sep 19, 2017
BDSM

Joe had been looking forward to a quiet weekend. The high-end renovation he had been hired to complete had a deadline and he had to bust his ass all week to get it completed on time. Now, with the deadline met and the check in hand, he was planning on watching baseball and drinking beer all weekend. He got up early to go for a run. He figured a good run woul...

Her Bejeweled Butt Plug

by unefemme on Sep 26, 2017
Anal

"Get the largest one they have." Those were the words I remembered as I searched the website for my new purchase, a red bejeweled butt plug crafted by a Frenchman. And how I was tempted to disobey, for they also sold smaller ones, ones that could be worn with little if any discomfort, more to what I thought would be my liking. But I didn't dare. The day...

A Birthday Butt Plug Surprise

by sunset_lover101 on Sep 12, 2017
Anal

Callie's birthday gifts started with the panties, lacy, see-through black ones. She'd torn open the small package and smiled at Toby. "Put them on, baby," he said as he brushed the red tissue paper off the bed. He resisted reaching for his wife as she stood over him, shimmied out of her dress, pressed her hand on his shoulder for support and stepped into the...

The Perfect Butt Plug

by TheBiProf on Feb 6, 2018
Anal

Walking through the aisles of the grocery store I must have a grin on my facing knowing I have a secret that no one could possibly guess. I pass all of the mothers doing their weekly shopping and I just want to stop one and tell her, "I have finally found the perfect butt plug and I'm wearing it right now!" I've always read that butt plugs give you a great...

Biker Revenge

by Sway01 on Aug 11, 2018
BDSM

After 12 years in prison, you've just been released. Yeah you were in a motorcycle gang, and sure you sold drugs, fucked whores and got into fights, but you were framed for murder. Now you're going to get the gang back together and get revenge on every last one of them. WRITERS: Feel free to add your own chapters and branches to this story. Please read the S...

Open in Reader

First Date Butt Plug Blues

by WinterSilvers on Mar 26, 2019
Anal

"No sandals, or flip flops. Put your hair in a ponytail." Was all that he would say when she asked about what to wear. She was told by her friend who had set them up that "He is weird, but worth it" so she wore Chuck's with her miniskirt. She put on the miniskirt to make herself feel sexy, she had been on blind dates before and knew how badly this one woul...

Princess Plug

by BigBunsLover on Sep 17, 2017
Loving Wives

So I'm surfing porn and come across photos of women with butt plugs. They are made of metal and have a jewel on them. Imagining sliding one into my wife's ass is making me very hard. We have never played with toys, but I find myself buying one online, staying so hard through the process that I start to leak pre-cum. My wife has a great ass. She is a little...