Butt Plugged Stories

95,161 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

More Fucked Up Fairy Tales

by TheBigandBaldGuy on Sep 14, 2017
Humor & Satire

Beauty and the "Beast" Once upon a time a merchant set off for market, where he planned to sell some his freshly harvested weed. Before he left he asked each of his three triplet daughters what she would like as a present for their 19th birthdays. The first daughter wanted a brocade dress, the second a pearl necklace, but the third, whose name was Beauty –...

Danny's Butt Mom Ch. 08

by Bob_Lovecock on Sep 12, 2017
Fetish

Warning: This story contains scat and poop scenes. If you don't like this sort of thing, this story is not for you. * * * * * He held on to his mother's hips as he pumped his load up her ass. When he was done he pulled out his big prick and his mom crawled over and put it in her mouth. "Oh yeah Mom! Suck it. Suck your ass off my dick." She bobbed her he...

Daniel and Jamie's Romantic Night Ch. 02

by lockedinsteel on Apr 17, 2019
Group Sex

Daniel woke up and realized that someone warm was pressed into his back, their arm draped over his side, their face nuzzled into his neck. As he opened his eyes he saw the clock and realized that it was later than usual, almost 10am. The events of the previous night came flooding back as his mind shook off the tendrils of sleep. He remembered submitting to...

The Widow at the Opera

by Beau_Jack_Walker on Aug 18, 2017
Fetish

WARNING: Taking wine enemas can kill you. A straight wine enema could cause alcohol poisoning. ------------------------------------------ I had met Polly Forbes at a surprise birthday party. We had been dating off and on for two years. I was way out of her class,but she seemed to like me anyway. Polly had taken me to her tailor and had him make a custom...

A Fuck Toy Graduation Episode 05

by Contrasting on Sep 10, 2018
BDSM

"What?" Taylor screamed. "You told them what?" Tim Stanton cringed. Taylor towered over him. She was naked, she was aroused, but wanton and wanting. Tim had had her for three days and she'd not come once with him. She'd been coddled close to the edge, escorted to the moment of delight but always the little shit left her wanting and empty, unfulfilled and d...

Judy's Turn

by skinnysailor on Nov 26, 2017
BDSM

Monday "Darling? What is this?" Such a beautiful soft voice. "Huh? It's the butt plug." "No, Darling. It's YOUR butt plug. I bought it just for you. Your butt plug." "Er, right my butt plug." "So? Why?" "Well, er, I'm going to work. Right? I mean as soon as I'm home tonight. Right?" "Sit for a moment Darling." He sits on a kitchen chair. Judy stays s...

Beth and the Plug Pt. 07

by mofguy on Sep 14, 2017
Sci-Fi & Fantasy

Beth awoke with a headache. She felt fine physically, but she felt like she just had an exhausting battle where she had to use even her last magic reserves to win. Didn't that kitsune told her that she will only take a "decent meal's worth" of mana and she, as a mage, should not worry about it? When she looked around, she was surprised that Irha, the kitsun...

Morning Mirror

by toast on Sep 17, 2017
BDSM

As directed by his internet Mistress, toast put on the heavy one inch thick sterling silver ring and began to prepare for bed. Adding a butt plug on his own initiative as another tribute to his Mistress, he realized he would have to tell her and be punished for not first asking her permission. He felt so desperately alone and longed for a Mistress to take hi...

Learning to Let Go Pt. 08

by Yoshimatsu on Sep 14, 2017
BDSM

Learning to Let Go is an 8 part continuous series; so if you were naughty and skipped ahead I urge you to start at the beginning or the following may make little sense. Welcome to Part 8. ***** 2010 Jen's arsehole was tight, but not as much as I had expected, and the butt plug slowly slipped deeper and deeper inside her with relative ease until the l...

Seeing My Ex-Husband's Big Cock Ch. 02

by Cute_Little_Muffin on Sep 28, 2020
Exhibitionist & Voyeur

(Note: I had a comment to part 1 saying I was being a bitch to my little Reggie, which really hurt. I've thought about it a lot, and all I can say is that my little Reggie is happy to play along with the whole thing, and so I can't see how I'm being a bitch? Sure, he's getting humiliated a teensy bit, but that's all part of the fun. In the end I might be par...