Buttplug Cyoa Stories

1,100 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

My New Masters Ch. 2

by jamiesecret on Sep 19, 2017
Fetish

I slept a fitful sleep that evening. I had started out the night by browsing for videos at the local porno shop. I was wearing women’s underwear, and a pair of large black men noticed my bra straps. These men subsequently took me to a house and raped my virgin ass and mouth. Afterward the men dumped me in an alley in my underwear, keeping my things including...

Jeet - An OFS Story Pt. 02

by OffNSFW on Oct 6, 2020
Fetish

"My vulva and my asscrack are still greasy from lubricant." PART 2: JEET'S COCK Okay, Jeet. My pussy needs filling. Fuck me with your cock. Stick your fist in there. Drive a damn truck through me. I don't care, just give me something. As if on cue, I feel him dragging me backwards. He lays me out on the bed, my legs dangling over the edge. He taps the i...

Kinky Secrets Ch. 14

by pvclook on Sep 26, 2017
Toys & Masturbation

Just a note to say thanks for all the encouragement. If you want some chapters early drop me a PM and I will add you to the list ------------------------ Come the morning Mary was a bit of a wreck. Being constantly kept on edge stopped her having a fitful sleep and by the time the alarm went off I was looking for any excuse to get out of bed. Mary wen...

Kinky Secrets Ch. 16

by pvclook on Sep 26, 2017
Toys & Masturbation

With all this slow fucking Mary orgasmed most of the night. Her juices running down the machine. The feeling of the ball expanding deep within her colon and moving down inside her. The pressure on the walls of her colon drove her to ecstasy. This was sometimes overridden by the expanding of the thick buttplug. This was expanded from very small to a diameter...

Roommate's Toys and Lingerie

by Roxyfox_y on May 12, 2020
Toys & Masturbation

Finally finding myself alone in my apartment for the afternoon I was ready to have some fun. My roommate has been home for most of the lockdown and I've been confined to my own room for my solo experiences. She told me this morning she was headed off to a friend's house for the afternoon. I knew it was time to expand my little world. I know it probably is...

The Haunted House Club Ch. 02

by Five_Eight on Sep 12, 2017
Anal

The graphic Halloween sexual adventures of a barely legal valley girl continue when she encounters a second masked man. And more! Although this story is complete in itself, reading THE HAUNTED HOUSE CLUB first will doubtless increase your enjoyment of Part Two. Some readers pointed out to me that in Part One the night had just begun, and they were not wrong....

A Slut Got Fucked Pt. 03

by bitch2015 on Sep 16, 2017
Group Sex

I woke up to a ticklish feeling in my cunt. I opened my eyes to welcome the sight of Dex trying to pull the buttplug out of my pussy. I realized that it was almost evening, I had lost the track of time. In a sudden tug Dex took out the plug and asked me to stand. As I stood up the cum ran down my thighs. Jim asked me to go and clean myself up quickly but I w...

Sextoys R' Us

by Svenskaflicka on Sep 12, 2017
Toys & Masturbation

-Jane... what is THIS? I looked up from my book, and turned red when I saw my boyfriend Alan hold up what looked like a prop from a Star Wars movie. -It's a dildo, I said. -A dildo? said Alan. It looks like a crystal sword to me. -Well, it is, sort of, I said, and took it from him. You hold it like this... and then you stab the pussy with it. -Sounds c...

My Gay Ex-Roommate Pt. 03

by 1077ad on Jun 19, 2018
Novels and Novellas

Over the next week, my brain kept exploding a little when I remembered what I had done at Alan's place. It was a huge distraction as the feelings, smells, and tastes flooded back in and pushed everything else out of my mind. I was surprised that while there was a sort of awkwardness about it, I didn't feel conflicted or ashamed or hung up that I'd had sexual...

Liquid Shower

by michaelhunt on Sep 14, 2017
Fetish

Collette and I hadn't participated in any scenes with Jeff & Rebecca or Lisa & Scott for a while. The kids had been a handful lately and our parents always seemed to be too busy to babysit them. We were having plenty of straight sex almost every night but there was no spontaneity to it. It was too mechanical, too planned. Collette surprised me one night rec...