First Butt Plug Stories Stories

1,000 results
Orientation
Length
Category
Source
Infinite Scroll
SmutMD: The World's Biggest Erotic Literature Search Engine.
© 2026 SmutMD.com
Create your own smut fantasy with AI

A Collection of First Times

by TotalKnockout on Dec 2, 2017
First Time

Author's Note: all of these stories are autobiographical and absolutely true accounts of some very hot "first times" I've had. Only the names have been changed. ***** ***Oliver: my first oral experience*** My very first experience with oral sex was when I was 18 years old and still a virgin. I was at one of my very first college parties, and I ran into...

Exploring Sexuality: A Pegging

by silkstockingslover on Sep 25, 2017
Anal

Summary: Husband is pegged by sister-in-law with wife's permission Note 1: Thanks to Robert, goamz86 and Wayne for editing. Exploring Sexuality: A Pegging I was almost in the city when my cell rang. I glanced at it and saw it was my sister-in-law Sabrina. I sighed. I loved Sabrina, but since her divorce she had been as exciting as a Nicholas Sparks mov...

Kevin's Sow Pt. 02: Watching Karen

by Wifeowner on Sep 26, 2017
BDSM

The orgasm was the most explosive one of my life. It literally knocked me off my feet and caused me to see spots before my eyes. I ended up panting on the floor with my panties around my knees. I didn't remember pulling them down, but I must have shimmied out of them to give my hand more leverage to fuck my molten sex. My skirt was pulled up above my hips...

A Lesson About Denial

by suede_knight on Sep 11, 2017
BDSM

My wife and I were laying on the couch together. It was early in the evening and TV seemed to be only reruns of sitcoms. She leaned in closer to cuddle. My mind thought how nice this was for a change but my body took it another way. I kissed and caressed her neck as innocently as I could but she was wise to the true intent of my affections. "Are you horny a...

The Bitchy Bitch

by nadia603000 on Sep 28, 2020
BDSM

Prologue: In case this is the first of my stories you've read, there are a few things I've skipped over in this story since there are several other stories I've written about this same sub. I tend to write a story after almost all of my sessions with my toys. But I publish very few of them online. My name is Pepper Rodgers. I'm a 19-year-old Domme, living...

At Last

by sweetjulia on Sep 15, 2017
Anal

It finally happened! I finally had a thick hard cock buried up to the balls in my willing open ass! I’ve had an anal fixation for years, but my husband was afraid of hurting me, anytime we’d tried it just was too painful for me, and so we stopped trying. But I was determined and I knew that others did it and enjoyed it we must have been doing something wro...

At Last

by julia so sweet on Sep 12, 2017
Anal

It finally happened! I finally had a thick hard cock buried up to the balls in my willing open ass! I've had an anal fixation for years, but my husband was afraid of hurting me, anytime we'd tried it just was too painful for me, and so we stopped trying. But I was determined and I knew that others did it and enjoyed it we must have been doing something wro...

Amber and the Mystery Cock

by GreenEyedAmber on Oct 6, 2020
Exhibitionist & Voyeur

Author's note: Dreamers Come Play is an alternate universe. Stories set in it may incorporate touches of magical realism, blurred dreams, and other unexplained phenomena. All events depicted are by characters at least 18 years of age. The prep school is a one year program run by the college for students between high school and university. All students in i...

Vanessa's Vocation

by Calandria on Sep 16, 2017
BDSM

This is a fantasy, needless to say – you may like it, or not. I never know where these stories are going when I start to write them .I don't know about you, I prefer fairly straight sex, but it's boring to read and write about, so here goes! * My name, for many long years, sounded to me like a joke. It sounded so sexy, so sophisticated, the name my parent...

Los Cinco Hermanos Ch. 10

by eidetic on Sep 15, 2017
Group Sex

Wherein a Night at the Movies becomes a tourist vacation with a slant Author's note: this is part 10 of a 12-part story arc which I've put under Group Sex (see Chapter 1). Like all my stories, it begins with character development and in this case, over several chapters. The chapters can have the elements of a number of different categories and I will try to...