Shay Stories

323 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Play Ball

by Baloo the Bear on Sep 16, 2017
Romance

Ken stared at the wall of video screens at the terminal. He had a knot in his stomach that had been there ever since Shay told him that she was flying into Boston a couple of weeks before. The knot was getting even tighter now. He was just grateful that her inbound flight to Logan was on time - having to wait any longer to hold her again would have been abso...

Conference in New York

by ShaylaStriffler on Nov 6, 2018
Erotic Couplings

Last summer, the company I work for hosted a conference in New York City. I'm based in their west coast office, and though I think I live in the greatest city in the world, I was excited to spend a few days in New York. I looked forward to taking advantage of some cultural experiences not readily available in San Francisco. Broadway shows, the best jazz club...

School Days, Rule Days

by komrad1156 on Sep 12, 2017
Mature

*Note to readers: This story has two endings. The first stops with the PG-13 version. Readers who want to find out what happens in the bedroom can find the adult version right after the new couple make their way toward it. ***** "Shay? We both know your father isn't coming back. Missing him is one thing but letting it affect your life is another." "I unde...

Movie Premiere

by Lazyninjas on Sep 17, 2017
Celebrities & Fan Fiction

Celebs: Shay Mitchell Codes: (MF, Cons, Oral, Exhib) Disclaimer: This story is fictional. None of this has ever happened or ever will happen. ***** "How do I look babe? Does this look sexy enough for a first red-carpet appearance?" my beautiful girlfriend Shay Mitchell asked me as she came out of her room and showed off the dress she planned to wear to...

A Day with Shay

by jjgarces on Sep 13, 2017
Celebrities & Fan Fiction

It's no secret that Shay Mitchell is one of the most personable celebrities on YouTube, and as such, she is one of the most likeable celebrities in the world. But even her assistant thought that her latest idea was crazy, and she didn't hesitate to tell her that. "Shay, are you sure about this? I mean, I'm sure there are a lot of your fans that would want...

The Pink Monster

by DirtyGeisha on Sep 16, 2017
Toys & Masturbation

I was in a surprisingly good mood today. I was walking home from the library at dusk. The world seemed alive, I felt alive. For some reason I was so happy I thought I would burst. I didn't even really miss him, much. Spring was finally here. I thought it would never arrive, but I think that every year. Usually, when I'm just about to give up hope spring arr...

Inverted

by MoodusSunset on Feb 12, 2019
Loving Wives

"The weekend had finally begun!" Sawyer exclaimed to Shay while doing an embarrassing little hip shake dance. "Just the two of us, alone, what a gift" Shay thought out loud. The neighbor's cars are nowhere to be seen and no sounds outside besides some birds could be heard. It was like the whole world has gone on vacation, so the lovers could be free with...

Love Conquers All

by komrad1156 on May 22, 2018
Mature

*Author's note: Insecurities seem trivial, and many are. Sometimes though, an insecurity is based on something real and gets so deeply internalized, it becomes a part of us, and occasionally, it can be debilitating. It could be anything from a lazy eye to unsightly teeth to morbid obesity to something as horrific as severe facial burns. Or it could be someth...

In the Garden...

by Sweet_Shay on Sep 17, 2017
Loving Wives

It was a beautiful day in June. Not just any day, It was Shay's birthday. Rick had asked for weeks what she would like to do on "her day." She would always reply, " I've had too many without you, I want this to be you and me doin nothin but hangin out with each other. All day and all night." He thought to himself it sounded like it was "his special day." H...

The Caramel Sutra

by cummybear on Sep 13, 2017
Erotic Couplings

******Happy Valentine's Day, baby****** He watched Shay's face as she rode him. She was getting that faraway look in her eyes and that subtle softness took over her features. As she picked up the pace of her gyrations on top of him, Ken slid his hands up her stomach, her skin glistening with sweat. Feeling his hands cup her breasts and press into her nipple...