Shay Stories

323 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Sunday Afternoon Tease Ch. 02

by Sweet_Shay on Sep 17, 2017
Loving Wives

(the beginning of this story is titled, Sunday Afternoon Tease) ~continued~ Rick stayed on the sofa waiting, thinking she would be coming from the bedroom in some skimpy little outfit and they would fuck like animals in the living room, then maybe the kitchen. He gripped his cock and stroked it effortlessly and waited. He had to get himself in check three...

The Other Woman

by jjgarces on Sep 16, 2017
Celebrities & Fan Fiction

I had been seeing Shay Mitchell, the sexy, and some would say, sexiest period, cast member of "Pretty Little Liars", for about six months, and we had just moved in to my place together when I first met Jana Kramer, the actress-turned-country-singer, after one of her concerts. And ever since then, we had been having an affair for at least half that long behi...

NYU Summer Break Threesome

by SluttyBisexualGuy on Mar 20, 2018
Group Sex

It was a beautiful Saturday morning as the light poured in through the windows of the third floor Greenwich Village loft apartment. Ryland Abernathy stirred beneath the thin cotton sheet as he felt the warmth of his girlfriend's body pressed up against his side. Her naked limbs tree-branched over his in a sidesaddle cocoon of familiar comfort. Her sun-kisse...

Colorado Memories

by Sweet_Shay on Sep 14, 2017
Erotic Couplings

Pack warm clothes...destination...Colorado. That was all she would tell him. They were in flight, about 30 minutes from landing, and he still had no idea what was going on in that pretty little head of hers. He trusted her though. He knew her well enough to know that anything she planned for the two of them, he would enjoy as long as they were together. Th...

2199 Pt. 01: Kumi and Shay

by thewayofphi on Jun 19, 2018
Fetish

The following is part of an elaborate story series that will explore a vast number of themes in kink. The themes explored in each chapter are highlighted beforehand so you can make your own decision if you would like to continue reading. All characters depicted are fictional and over 18 years of age. If you enjoyed all or any of it or if you have any feedba...

The Playmates of 1969

by hopeolsonfan on Sep 17, 2017
Celebrities & Fan Fiction

Most of the playmates of 1969 were already in the large dressing room at the mansion and the room was buzzing with excitement. The girls were giggling and teasing each other as they wriggled into bunny costumes; the girls who actually worked as bunnies helped the others get into the revealing outfits. Nobody had told them what was going on except that it was...

Tequila & Peaches

by Baloo the Bear on Sep 13, 2017
Erotic Couplings

Shay was smiling to herself as she removed the bottle of Jose Cuervo from the liquor cabinet. She had been really laying the tease on Ken pretty heavy in the local bar they met in a few weeks earlier. She had finally asked him over for dinner and before she knew it, their teasing had escalated into a challenge. Shay loved Tequila Shots and they had come to...

Fucking the Little Liars Ch. 06

by jjgarces on Sep 26, 2017
Celebrities & Fan Fiction

I was still basking in the glow of the great sex I had with Troian in her trailer when I arrived on set a few days later after a break in production had given us a few days off. As usual, I couldn't wait to finish the work day and hopefully spend some time alone with some of the girls again, bit as it turns out, I wasn't going to have to wait that long this...

Little Fluffy Love

by riversong96 on Sep 16, 2017
Romance

We were watching a movie, like we always did, since I was twelve and he was seventeen. Even after losing contact for years we started back our traditions on our own once we found ourselves to live close again, without the usual group of friends. But then why did something feel different this time? Was it that me and my boyfriend were having troubles, have...

Phantom Limb

by CycleWriter on Jul 29, 2019
Erotic Couplings

Her body was perfection, sleek as a cat, tapered thighs and muscular calves, dangerous ass curves and precipitously sloped breast mounds. Hers were the kind of long, elegant, sensuous lines that draw the eye to it, and certainly were drawing Carl's. Her physical form was a bold and even defiant statement that spoke powerfully of the mystery and promise and p...