Surprise Creampie Stories

137,098 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Please Don't Say Yes

by aika092 on Dec 2, 2020
Fetish

You live with your fiancée Cassandra. Your love is deep, devoted and true, and you are getting married in three months. She's the perfect girl for you - a little shy and somewhat "average looking" and unassuming, but also just the best person on earth. Always thinking of others, always knowing what is the right thing to do, and always the champion...

Open in Reader

Work Benefits

by justsomeguy41 on Apr 15, 2020
Anal

Note: Liked the idea of work benefits based free use stuff but got bored half way through so didn't go through with the original plan to slowly work up the mature corporate ladder. Lots of anal, ass to mouth and creampie swallowing like always. ~ The company was abuzz because of the new incentive plan HR had just rolled out. None of us had ever seen or h...

Keeping up with the Neighbors Ch. 02

by Billyglide on Sep 26, 2017
Fetish

A few days ago, my girlfriend, Nancy, convinced me to eat her pussy after I had cum in her. Her friend, Marcy, had told Nancy, that her husband would eat her creampie after they had sex. Marcy told Nancy that it gave the her strongest orgasms of her life when he did it. That same night, Nancy told me what Marcy had confided in her. I told her that it sound...

An Eventful Life Ch. 04

by Dirty1010Man on Sep 17, 2017
Loving Wives

Nearly two months had passed since the day Gen skipped out on dinner to have a sexual rendezvous with our old friends Josh and Todd. With both of us working now our lives were getting busier and time together was not taken for granted. We had enjoyed nights out together recently, going out to dinner and seeing movies and even though the eventfulness of our l...

The Story of N Day 07

by shortonreality on Jun 19, 2018
Sci-Fi & Fantasy

1) I don't know about you, but this particular episode gets me really turned on. And there are no "other men" in the way that some of you may find gross. 2) These things take forever! I've got many, many pages of half-written notes and text, but turning them into a story...not so easy. So I'm sorry about typos etc., but I figured you're probably not readin...

Annika's Coming of Age Party

by GateKeeper_A on Mar 26, 2018
Group Sex

It was Annika's birthday, her eighteenth birthday to be specific. Annika is a gamer, doesn't matter if its playing games on Steam, rolling dice around the table while playing Pathfinder, playing Magic or Pokemon, or playing miniatures games like Warhammer. She loved to game. Best part is, her parents were going to be out of town for a whole week, and her fri...

Open in Reader

That Creampie Smile

by rick_oh on Sep 12, 2017
Fetish

The way that Gina roped me into creampie dessert was gradual. Now I know that she had plans from the start, and impeccably carried them out step by step. She knew that her smile dazzled the guys, and used that fact to her advantage. I remember my first night at her apartment. We had gone there after dinner, and were talking. She flashed me that smile -- eye...

Naivety

by nymphette on Jun 4, 2018
Amateur

Alice Marie Fairborn opened her narrow cerulean eyes for the first time in 9 hours, her arms stretched in an energizing motion before leaping off her velvet-draped bed in happiness. She was finally out of high school! She had turned eighteen a week before, and spent it at the local church she and her parents attended every Sunday. Unlike most of her classmat...

Open in Reader

Creampie Wishes

by milfleglover on Sep 25, 2017
Mature

"C'mon honey, please, please, just do it!" "I...I can't, baby...I just can't!" "But you promised! You said you wanted to, please do it!" "That was before, I..I always want to before but after I...I just can't..." I looked down between my spread thighs, feeling foolish. I was begging my husband to eat my pussy after he'd just fucked me, something we'd bot...

Creampie Vignettes

by rick_oh on Aug 18, 2017
Fetish

I am currently dating three women. One of them, Veronica, I've been seeing for about three months. The others, Melissa and Joanie, are newer. In fact, Melissa and I got together in bed for the first time last week. There is a characteristic that all the women share - they all like me to perform oral sex on them after I ejaculate inside them. They didn't sta...