Unwanted Cream Pie Stories

64,760 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

A Pie at Last

by DiggerDave on Sep 13, 2017
Loving Wives

At last I got my cream pie! And I want to tell you how it happened. I have been married to Angela for the last sixteen years, and it has been generally a happy marriage. Angie was a virgin when we met and until recently she had only experienced my cock. We married at twenty after meeting each other in a club, and now aged thirty-six Angie still looks good....

Gumdrop Ch. 11

by bushyTrail on Jul 1, 2019
Fetish

Author's note: 10 chapters published, 10 more until the end. Gumdrop's story has reached its turning point, in more ways than one... Also, a new kind of pet is going to appear soon, so stay tuned! As absurd as the concept of a hucow is, I tried to take it quite seriously, to delve in the psychology of a hucow and her owner, in search of what this admittedl...

Cherry Pie

by fantaseeboy on Sep 13, 2017
Fetish

For as long as I can remember, I've loved to cook. It started when I was very young and I'd help my mother in the kitchen. Eventually I began baking on my own and slowly moved to preparing entire meals. But I'd always loved baking desserts the most. People seemed to enjoy those much more than anything else I made. After several years, I started playing with...

Cleaning Katy

by DiggerDave on Sep 26, 2017
Fetish

I thrust my cock deep into Kate's slippery wet pussy. As her internal muscles clamped hard round my erection, I groaned as I came. I spurted my load of sperm deep inside her tight little wet pussy. Kate and I have been married for ten years now. I am aged 34 and Kate is 30. We both have good professional jobs, which between us earn a good income. We haven't...

Key Lime Pie

by Gentle_Mistress on Sep 2, 2017
Erotic Couplings

I hear the door open and close again. I call out "Darling, I made your favourite – Key Lime Pie." "Hey, thanks." I hear him say, as he empties his pockets on the hall table. "I'm in the bedroom." I hear his footsteps coming down the hallway. He enters the bedroom and does a double-take, while I grin broadly at him. I am lying naked on a clean white shee...

Gumdrop Ch. 16

by bushyTrail on Jul 30, 2019
Fetish

Author's note: WARNING: There is the tiniest touch of reluctance/non-consent and scat in this chapter. Oddly, I don't like either much, but they were necessary for the evolution of the plot. As absurd as the concepts of hucows and ponygirls are, I tried to take them quite seriously, to delve in the psychology of a hucow or a ponygirl and her owner, in sear...

Pumpkin Cream Pie

by zach55 on Sep 15, 2017
Erotic Horror

It was a cool night in October; I was taking the garbage down to the road as I did every Wednesday night. My wife and I live out in the country on a gravel road and the only house nearby is an abandoned one at the bottom of my lane. It's about a quarter mile down to the road and sometimes I must admit a little scary. It was a cloudy evening so it was darke...

My Very First Cream Pie

by houstonbicouple on Sep 13, 2017
Loving Wives

Betty and I had been sharing our bed with others for a few years. With very few exceptions it was always with another couple, David and Sherry. During those early years Betty and David would pair up and me with Sherry, but we'd always have sex in separate rooms. A few times we were all naked and petted in front of one another but I never saw Betty have sex w...

William and Lois

by Bespectacledfantasist on May 1, 2018
Fetish

"So I can do anything I want so long as I also do it to myself?" William nodded, handcuffed to a chair and wearing just a white shirt and his boxer shorts. Lois stood over him wearing one of his shirts and presumably and some panties. Lois looked around the room, staring at the pies, gateaux's and the assorted gooey substances scattered about. "Where to s...

Gumdrop Ch. 14

by bushyTrail on Jul 16, 2019
Fetish

Author's note: As absurd as the concepts of hucows and ponygirls are, I tried to take them quite seriously, to delve in the psychology of a hucow or a ponygirl and her owner, in search of what these admittedly strange fetishes mean, at least to me. Therefore, beside the tropes of the genre (kinky sex, humiliation and de-humanization), you will find the musi...