Unwanted Cream Pie Stories

64,760 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Closing Up Early

by halfsummer on Sep 13, 2017
Erotic Couplings

It was eleven o'clock at Dolce Ice Cream, half an hour before closing time, and my feet and hands were killing me. No, seriously, absolutely throbbing. I readjusted my official baseball hat and retied my ponytail. My hair was dark brown with red tones underneath; leftover from a few months back when I had impulsively dyed my hair bright scarlet, looked in th...

I Dare You Pt. 02

by CaffeineFetish on Aug 28, 2018
Romance

York finished his workout and ate some yogurt and a piece of fruit the moment he stepped through the door. Tossing the banana peel into the trash with the yogurt cup, he stepped straight into the bathroom and started the shower. He closed the door to the room and undressed, then extended his hand around the curtain to test the water. When it was hot York st...

Return to Cheju-Do: A Sequel

by PrevertOne on Sep 11, 2017
NonHuman

Return to Cheju-Do (A Sequel to Horror at Cheju-Do Island by Doc Dweeb) By The Preve (with the Doc's permission) Thanks to Todger 65 for the edit. Author's note: This story is a sequel to an earlier one by Doc Dweeb, found on Monsters and Angels/Galaxy of Terror. In the previous story, the protagonist, while vacationing on a resort island off the souther...

Twelve Nights Ch. 07

by Daevious on Sep 17, 2017
BDSM

Part 7. Mandy stretched like a cat, responding to something tickling her feet. Sandra was sitting at her feet, running a feather over Mandy's toes. "Hey, stop that… It tickles." Sandra smiled shyly, "I know, grumpy. It's time for breakfast. I had to do this or start playing with you; I think this is more likely to get you out of bed. And I'm hungry." She...

Ice Cream Orgasm

by girlwithadirtymind on Sep 14, 2017
Fetish

Her first date with the sexy Ross was growing closer, and Sue was feeling more and more anxious about meeting the charming fella. After he had asked her out at the gym, they had been exchanging simmering looks for months. They always checked out each other's perspiring bodies, and that particular day, they had chatted for the first time near the sit-up area....

Fitting Room Mishaps

by nudedude03 on Jan 28, 2020
Exhibitionist & Voyeur

It was only a couple of days to spring break and I needed some new beach wear. I decided to get my stuff here in town so I wouldn't waste any valuable beach time once there. Unfortunately In the small college town there was only one store that sold that type of clothing, made sense since we were nowhere near any rivers, lakes much less the ocean. This s...

Stag Party Striptease Ch. 01

by Annatartywife on Sep 13, 2017
Exhibitionist & Voyeur

Since meeting Louise and Simon we have become good friends and have recently met up again for some nice horny fun. Simon had been chatting with Mike and mentioned a guy at his local golf club was getting married. Not someone he knows very well, just a member who he has had the occasional game with and a drink with. The guy had mentioned his sons upcoming m...

Whatever It Takes?

by Misslexia on Sep 15, 2017
Transsexuals & Crossdressers

It was a classic 'eyes meeting across a crowed room' moment when I met Penny. It was a Thursday night and I was at a corporate function where the firm I worked for were trying to drum up new business. Penny represented one of the companies that had received an invite. I had noticed her as soon as she walked in; elegantly dressed she looked beautiful, with he...

A Fireside Seduction

by KittyKatt on Sep 16, 2017
Romance

I glance around the room, checking to make sure everything is in order. Tonight will be very special. My seduction has been well planned. The wine is chilling next to a bowl of fresh strawberries and cream. The fire is slowly burning and the pillows are all arranged in front of it. The candles are ready to be lit And soft music is playing in the background....

Lady Arndale Ch. 02

by Pilot4029 on Sep 17, 2017
BDSM

Lady Arndale could have easily applied the cream herself but had asked me to do it instead. The bruising on her arse where I had smacked her with the hairbrush wasn’t too bad, but I knew she enjoyed the sensation of me rubbing the cream on her. I shouldn’t have been there at all of course, it was nearly seven in the morning, I started my work as a gardener...