Surprise Creampie Stories

137,098 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Banana Creampie

by Mushrum on Sep 12, 2017
Loving Wives

George Williams was nearing his sixty-fourth birthday. Genetic luck of the draw had gifted him with a tall body which easily retained its trim and athletic tone, helped along by moderate exercise. He even had managed to keep a (reasonably) full head of hair, albeit gray now instead of the dark brown of his youth. He had never been considered handsome, but a...

Accidental Dick Magic

by Supercali50 on Oct 2, 2020
Amateur

[Please hit “start game” so that the variables and conditions work properly!] Matt’s heart almost beat backwards. He was in his living room illuminated only by the TV, his girlfriend draped over him softly. It wasn’t that he really cared for Lucy that had him so anxious, though that played a part. Tonight was special. Matt has just turned 18 a few weeks ago,...

Open in Reader

Homemade Pie

by DiggerDave on Sep 12, 2017
Fetish

Before I continue with my story I will introduce you to myself. My name is Alan and I am forty three years old. I have been married to Pam for twenty years now and we are both happy with each other. We have never had any children. This year Pam turned forty and still looks great. She has dark brown hair which she cuts short in a bob which curves in to the na...

Shuichi's Sexy Psyche Taxi

by cloud8745 on Jun 7, 2019
Fan Fiction

“Augh… another long day at the office…” Shuichi Saihara sighed to himself as he leaned back in his office chair. His black suit, short black hair, and blue tie reflected off the dark computer as it powered down and he began to gather his things into his leather bag to go home. His silver eyes were tired and withdrawn from staring at a computer screen all day...

Open in Reader

Creampie Lover Ch. 02

by jealouscuck on Sep 26, 2017
Fetish

In the previous chapter, I shared how I met Cynthia and how our relationship had survived our first crisis. After we resumed our hot sex, we played hard and steady for about a month. However, one evening during some hot oral sex, she started talking dirty. She was saying things like, "Shove your big cock up my hot cunt." It excited me and I shot my load into...

Karyn Delivers My First Creampie

by Lyks2BTeezd on Sep 2, 2017
Fetish

My first creampie was memorable. One year on my birthday, Karyn, my wife, and I woke up in the morning and were snuggling in bed. I had to fly out of town in a few hours on business. During this period in our marriage Karyn had a regular lover that she was seeing several times a week. (Also see my story View from the Stairs.) Up to this time they had been pr...

Rise of a Free Love Empire

by BelleHades on Sep 26, 2017
Science Fiction

Gene's workday began like any other; get up at 9:30, get ready for the day, and leave for work at 10:30 on the town's local bus service. Today was a Friday, so he was grateful for the end of another work week. His job? A dishwasher at the local burger joint. Exciting, right? About him, Gene was 29 years old, and his 30th birthday is tomorrow. Go Gene, right?...

Open in Reader

Slut Camp

by yournewbestfriend on Aug 11, 2015
Erotic Couplings

Note: though I do refer to some of the characters as "children," all of the characters in this story are over 18. "Goddammit Sam! Can you stop that!" Paul Archer has had enough. Every time he or his wife Claudia needs to find one of their children, they always wind up walking in on them masturbating. Whether it's Jeremy jerking off into h...

Open in Reader

Double Dessert

by bjking on Sep 19, 2017
Fetish

For a long time now, I've loved the idea of eating my wife's pussy right after I cum inside her. I fantasize about it practically every time we have sex, but unfortunately, as soon as I cum I lose interest completely. In fact, after I cum the idea repels me. I've mentioned this fantasy to Pam, and much to my surprise it turned her on at least as much as it d...

Lauren's Surprise Creampie

by sunniex on Sep 14, 2017
Fetish

This is a true story from about 18 months ago. I didn't even see it coming! My girl Lauren and I had a date to go to a Christmas party. We went, had a great time, drinks, food the works. Then she reminds me that an old friend of hers is passing through town and is going to be here that night. She said they were just old school friends, had never been lovers,...